CritHit Deals

Humble Choice vs. buying games on sale, with today's prices

Deals › Blog › Is Humble Choice worth it?

Is Humble Choice worth it?

Some 'Get deal' links are affiliate links: we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. (disclosure)

By CritHit Staff · Published 2026-11-05 · Updated 2026-11-17

Is it worth it?: Humble Choice pays for itself when the games you'd really play cost more than the $14.99 membership at today's cheapest authorized prices. This month the 2 cheapest games together already top that, so any 2 games you'd play cover it. If only one title appeals, buy it on sale instead.

How Humble Choice works

November 2026 lineup vs. today's prices

The November 2026 Choice runs until December 1, 2026, with 5% going to Covenant House. Humble lists a redeem-by date of June 1, 2027 on these keys. Here is what the same games cost at authorized PC stores today:

GameCheapest todaySteam todayLowest recorded
Mafia: The Old Country + 2 DLC packs
Steam key; the Gatto Nero and Padrino DLC packs are not counted in the price
$41.99 at GameBillet$49.99$24.99
The Outer Worlds 2
Battle.net key on Choice; price shown is the PC base game
$67.19 at Fanatical$69.99$32.19
SHINOBI: Art of Vengeance
Steam key
$14.99 at Steam$14.99$13.46
Yakuza 6: The Song of Life
Steam key
$9.99 at Steam$9.99$4.94
Crisol: Theater of Idols
Steam key
$17.99 at Steam$17.99$13.48
Space Haven
Steam key
$9.99 at GOG$24.99$9.19
DYSMANTLE
Steam key
$6.99 at GOG$19.99$4.59
Squeakross: Home Squeak Home
Steam key
$14.99 at Steam$14.99$11.24

Bought separately at today's cheapest authorized prices, the 8 base games add up to $184.12 (regular prices: $247.92). 3 of them cost more than $14.99 on their own today: The Outer Worlds 2 ($67.19), Mafia: The Old Country ($41.99), and Crisol: Theater of Idols ($17.99). The cheapest to buy alone are DYSMANTLE ($6.99), Yakuza 6: The Song of Life ($9.99), and Space Haven ($9.99).

That headline total only matters if you want most of the lineup. A smaller test: the two cheapest base games, DYSMANTLE ($6.99) and Yakuza 6: The Song of Life ($9.99), come to $16.98 at today's cheapest authorized prices, which is already more than the $14.99 monthly price. The test that matters is the games you'd actually play: add up their prices in the table, and if the total beats $14.99, the month is worth it.

Who Humble Choice is a good fit for

Who should skip it

Monthly or annual plan?

The annual plan costs $154.99, about $12.92 a month instead of $14.99, so it saves about $25 over a year if you would take all 12 months. Humble's FAQ says buying the annual plan unlocks the current month right away and stores 11 monthly credits. If you skip a month, you still need to do it before that month's billing date. The annual plan makes sense if you already buy Choice most months. If you dip in only a few times a year, monthly plus skipping is cheaper.

A quick checklist before you pay

  1. Wait for the first-Tuesday reveal and read the full lineup.
  2. List only the games you would actually play.
  3. Check each one's current price and lowest recorded price on CritHit (or the table above).
  4. If your list costs more than $14.99 in total, join or stay for that month. If not, skip before the last Tuesday.
  5. After you unlock a month, redeem the keys soon, because publishers can set expiry dates.

Humble Store deals today

Current discounts at the Humble Store from today's data (non-member prices) · checked 2026-11-18:

GRAVEN

Humble Store · Action, Adventure · compare 10 stores
-85%$24.99$3.74
Get deal

Deponia

Humble Store · Adventure, Indie · Metacritic 74 · compare 9 stores
-90%$9.99$0.99
Get deal

Blackguards 2

Humble Store · Adventure, Indie · Metacritic 74 · compare 10 stores
-90%$9.99$0.99
Get deal

The Dark Eye: Chains of Satinav

Humble Store · Adventure, Indie · Metacritic 75 · compare 9 stores
-90%$19.99$1.99
Get deal

Tails of Iron

Humble Store · Action, Adventure · Metacritic 81 · compare 11 stores
-88%$24.99$2.99
Get deal

Eldest Souls

Humble Store · Action, Adventure · Metacritic 76 · compare 12 stores
-90%$19.99$1.99
Get deal

Tower 57

Humble Store · Action, Indie · Metacritic 72 · compare 8 stores
-90%$11.99$1.19
Get deal

Milanoir

Humble Store · Metacritic 75 · compare 3 stores
-90%$12.99$1.29
Get deal

The break-even, one game at a time (2026-11-18)

Add the lineup up from the cheapest game, using today's cheapest authorized price for each. The first row where the total passes $14.99 is the point where the membership starts paying for itself.

Games you'd playAddsRunning totalVersus the $14.99 membership
1DYSMANTLE ($6.99 at GOG)$6.99less than the membership
2Yakuza 6: The Song of Life ($9.99 at Steam)$16.98more than the membership
3Space Haven ($9.99 at GOG)$26.97more than the membership
4SHINOBI: Art of Vengeance ($14.99 at Steam)$41.96more than the membership
5Squeakross: Home Squeak Home ($14.99 at Steam)$56.95more than the membership
6Crisol: Theater of Idols ($17.99 at Steam)$74.94more than the membership
7Mafia: The Old Country + 2 DLC packs ($41.99 at GameBillet)$116.93more than the membership
8The Outer Worlds 2 ($67.19 at Fanatical)$184.12more than the membership

Prices are the cheapest tracked authorized price on 2026-11-18, the same ones as the lineup table above, summed by us. They move daily; the membership price is Humble's.

If you're weighing this against other ways to build a library, how bundles work, building a library on a budget and price alerts cover the alternatives, and Steam or a key shop helps when a game is on both.

FAQ

How much does Humble Choice cost?

In the US, Humble Choice costs $14.99 for a monthly plan or $154.99 for an annual plan (about $12.92 a month), according to Humble's Choice FAQ. Prices differ by region and can change, so check the price at checkout.

Do I keep the games if I cancel Humble Choice?

Yes. Humble says you can cancel at any time without losing content you have already paid for. Some keys carry a publisher expiry date, so redeem them on Steam or the stated platform soon after you unlock a month.

When does Humble Choice charge me, and how do I skip a month?

Existing members are auto-billed on the last Tuesday of each month at 10 AM Pacific. New games are revealed on the first Tuesday of the month, so you can see the lineup first and skip from your account settings before the last Tuesday to avoid the charge. A skip lasts one month.

What happens to the Humble Store discount if I skip?

Members get a growing Humble Store discount: 10% for 1-2 consecutive months, 15% for 3-5, 17% for 6-11 and 20% at 12 or more. Humble says skipping a month or canceling resets it to 10%.

Is Humble Choice better than waiting for a Steam sale?

Only if you want several games in that month's lineup. If you want just one game and it costs less than $14.99 at an authorized store, buying it on sale is cheaper. If two or more games you would actually play add up to more than $14.99, Choice usually wins.

Related guides

Humble Choice prices, perks, billing and skip rules are summarized from humblebundle.com/membership and Humble Support, checked 2026-11-05. Game prices come from CheapShark's tracked stores and refresh with each rebuild. CritHit isn't paid by Humble for this guide. Spot an error? Email hello@crithitdeals.com.

Best deals · All PC deals · ← All posts