CritHit Deals

Authorized key stores vs gray-market marketplaces, explained

Are game key sites legit? Official stores vs key resellers

Short answer: it depends on where the key comes from. Many stores outside Steam sell Steam keys legitimately: developers request those keys from Valve specifically to sell on other stores. The risk comes from marketplaces where anyone can resell a key and the store can't show where it came from.

How a legitimate Steam key gets to a store

Valve's Steamworks documentation on Steam Keys says keys are a free service Valve gives developers "to help you sell your game on other stores and at retail". A developer or publisher requests keys, then supplies them to retailers it chooses. When you buy from one of those retailers, the developer has agreed to that sale.

Authorized stores vs gray-market marketplaces

Authorized storeOpen key marketplace
Who sells the keyThe store itself, supplied by the publisher or developerThird-party sellers listing keys on the platform
Where keys come fromDirect from the publisher or developerOften unknown to the buyer
Does the developer get paid for the sale?Yes, under its deal with the storeNot for the resale
Main riskLow: normal store supportA key can be revoked later if it was stolen or bought fraudulently

Why a resold key can stop working

Valve lets developers ban keys. Its documentation says developers may "revoke keys that have been stolen or purchased fraudulently", and it warns developers that "fraudsters impersonating journalists or storefronts" obtain keys "and then resell those keys for profit" (source). If a key you bought from an unknown reseller is later banned, the game can be removed from your account, and your recourse is with the marketplace, not Valve or the developer.

How to check a key store

Which stores CritHit Deals lists

We don't pick stores by hand. All prices come from CheapShark, which tracks a fixed list of digital stores, and CritHit shows only stores in that list. It does not include open key marketplaces. In today's build (2026-11-18), the cheapest price for at least one game came from: DreamGame, Epic Games Store, Fanatical, GOG, GameBillet, GamersGate, Gamesplanet, GreenManGaming, Humble Store, IndieGala, Steam, Uplay, WinGameStore. Prices on game pages come from: DreamGame, Epic Games Store, Fanatical, GOG, GameBillet, GamersGate, Gamesplanet, GreenManGaming, Humble Store, IndieGala, Steam, Uplay, WinGameStore.

Some links to these stores are affiliate links. That never changes which stores appear or how deals rank; see our affiliate disclosure.

Where today's cheapest prices come from (2026-11-18)

StoreGames where it is the cheapest tracked price
WinGameStore54
GOG52
Gamesplanet28
Epic Games Store24
Uplay14
Humble Store12
Steam12
GameBillet6
IndieGala5
GreenManGaming4
Fanatical3
GamersGate2
DreamGame1

This only shows where each store is cheapest today. It is not a safety ranking, and a low price alone is not a reason to trust a seller.

Related guides

FAQ

Are key resellers regulated or certified?

There is no official certification or licence for game key sellers. Valve does not certify or list approved key stores. What separates a safe store is whether it gets keys directly from the game's publisher or developer (an authorized retailer) or lets third parties resell keys of unknown origin. Normal consumer-protection and payment rules apply to any store, but they don't tell you where a key came from.

How can I tell if a key store is authorized?

Check whether the store sells keys itself rather than hosting many independent sellers, whether the game's publisher or developer names the store as a retail partner, and whether it has a clear refund policy and company contact details. A price far below every official store is a warning sign.

What happens if a key I bought gets revoked?

Valve lets developers revoke keys that were stolen or bought fraudulently. If that happens, the game can be removed from your Steam account. Valve and the developer won't refund a key you bought elsewhere, so your only recourse is the store or marketplace that sold it.

Are bundle stores like Humble and Fanatical legit?

Yes. Major bundle stores sell keys supplied by publishers and developers under agreements, which makes them authorized sellers. Our game bundles guide explains how bundle keys work.

Is buying a key cheaper than buying on Steam?

Sometimes. Authorized key stores can undercut Steam, but often the price is the same. Our Steam vs key shops guide explains when the store you pick matters.

Sources

Best deals this week · Best PC games under $10 · All deals