How to Tell If a Game Sale Is Actually a Good Deal

Blog › How to Tell If a Game Sale Is Actually a Good Deal

Quick answer: a sale is good when today's price is at or close to the game's lowest recorded price, it's the edition you want, recent reviews are positive, the store is authorized and you'll play it soon. The percentage off doesn't tell you any of that. On 2026-11-18, 215 tracked PC deals are 50% off or more, and only 60 of them are at their record low.

A big red percentage tells you very little. What counts is where today's price sits against the lowest price the game has ever hit, and whether you will actually play it. Below is the one-minute check we use, followed by a worked example from today's feed (2026-11-18).

1. Compare against the price history, not the regular price

The single most useful number is a game's lowest recorded price. Stores show a discount relative to the current list price, and that list price can be higher than what most people ever pay. If a game has been 75% off four times this year, a 50% sale is not special. If a game has never been cheaper than 40% off, a 50% sale is worth paying attention to.

Every game page on CritHit shows the lowest price CheapShark has recorded for it across the stores it tracks, along with the date. When today's price matches that record, we mark it, and when it's also at least 50% off, we call it a Lightning Deal. That label is generated from data, not chosen by hand.

2. Check which edition is on sale

Publishers often sell several editions of the same game: Standard, Deluxe, Gold, Ultimate, Complete. The differences can be cosmetic items, a season pass, expansions or early access. A "Gold Edition" at 85% off can be a better deal than the Standard edition at 70% off if it includes an expansion you'd buy anyway, or a worse one if the extras are skins you'll never use. Our guide to game editions covers how to compare them.

3. Look at reviews from players who've played recently

A game's Metacritic score tells you how critics rated it at launch. Its Steam review rating tells you what players think, and Steam lets you filter for recent reviews. Recent reviews matter most for older games, which can have problems with modern PCs, and for online games, whose communities and servers change over time. If a game depends on online multiplayer, check whether people are still playing it before you buy it cheaply.

4. Make sure the store is authorized

A price that's far below every official store is a warning sign. Open key marketplaces let anyone resell keys, and keys obtained fraudulently can be revoked later, removing the game from your library. Every store CritHit lists comes from CheapShark's fixed list of digital stores, which doesn't include open marketplaces. Our explainer Are game key sites legit? goes deeper.

5. Know the refund window before you buy

Sales encourage impulse buying, and that's fine if you can get your money back. Steam, GOG and the Epic Games Store all have refund policies, but they differ in time limits and conditions. Third-party key stores have their own rules, and many won't refund a key once it's revealed. Read our refund policy comparison so you know the safety net before you click buy.

6. Decide whether to wait for a seasonal sale

Steam's big seasonal sales (Spring, Summer, Autumn and Winter) bring broad discounts, and Valve publishes their dates ahead of time on its Steamworks site. We list every officially announced date on our Steam sale dates page. If a game is at a modest discount and a seasonal sale is a couple of weeks away, waiting can make sense. But not every game takes part in every sale, and a game at its lowest recorded price today may not be cheaper during the next event.

7. Ask whether you'll actually play it

The cheapest game is the one you don't buy. A library full of unplayed games bought at 90% off still costs money. Our rule of thumb: buy it if you'd play it in the next month, and wishlist it otherwise. Wishlists also let stores notify you when a game goes on sale; see our guide to wishlists and price alerts.

Worked example: same discount, different verdicts (2026-11-18)

We took today's 215 deals at 50% off or more and compared each price with the lowest price CheapShark has recorded for that game. 60 match their record low, 100 are close to it, and 55 have been cheaper before. "Close" means within 25% of the record plus 50 cents. The table shows the best-reviewed examples of each kind.

GameTodayOffLowest recordedAbove the recordVerdictReviews
Deus Ex: Human Revolution - Director's Cut$1.99−90%$1.99$0.00At its record lowMetacritic 91
Bzzzt$2.39−80%$2.39$0.00At its record lowMetacritic 91
Super Hexagon$0.75−75%$0.29+$0.46Close to its record lowMetacritic 88
Psychonauts$1.49−85%$0.89+$0.60Close to its record lowMetacritic 87
Desperados III$6.99−83%$3.57+$3.42Has been cheaperMetacritic 86
Nioh: Complete Edition$7.49−85%$4.24+$3.25Has been cheaperMetacritic 84

Read the last two columns, not the red tag. Desperados III is 83% off today, yet it has sold for $3.57, which is $3.42 less than today's $6.99. The games at the top of the table are the ones to buy if you want them. The ones at the bottom are wishlist candidates.

A quick checklist

If you can answer yes to most of these, it's a good deal. You can start with today's best-rated deals, where every game links to a page with its full price comparison and history.

Prices and store policies change. This guide reflects what we could verify on 2026-10-26; if you spot something out of date, email hello@crithitdeals.com.

← All posts