CritHit Deals

CritHit Staff buying checklist — verify the game, then compare every tracked offer

Deals › Blog › PC Game Pass vs Buying: A Game-by-Game Worksheet

PC Game Pass vs Buying: A Game-by-Game Worksheet

By CritHit Staff · Published 2026-11-08 · Updated 2026-11-08

Compare access to the particular game you want, not a subscription slogan against a sale percentage. The useful question is whether your planned access, platform, and content needs justify your own incremental cost. There is no universal number of games or hours that makes a subscription cheaper for everyone.

We checked Xbox’s official PC Game Pass page on November 8, 2026. Its FAQ says catalog access lasts until the subscription is canceled or expires, or until a game leaves the library. Titles, features, and availability vary by time, region, plan, and platform. Check Xbox’s current numeric price and your actual renewal terms yourself; this worksheet quotes no monthly rate.

Fill in one row per game

InputYour subscription routeYour purchase route
Exact game / edition / PC platformIs this title currently included in your region and plan?Which store license, launcher, and edition would you buy?
Access you already paid forRecord your paid-through date; separate existing access from future renewal spend.Record an already-owned compatible license, if any.
New money requiredEnter the actual additional billed periods, tax, and any verified promotion/renewal terms.Enter the current offer total, tax, and required extras from your checkout.
Planned useEnter when you realistically intend to play and whether continued catalog membership is essential.Enter whether you want to revisit after that period.
DLC and edition contentsCheck whether the desired expansion is actually included; list separately paid add-ons.Check base-game requirements and the exact included add-ons.
Catalog or service riskRecheck the current catalog and any official leaving notice; do not invent an expiry date.Check any required online service, outside account, and publisher notice.
Save / device compatibilityVerify the game-specific platform and save-transfer rules.A Steam purchase does not automatically import an Xbox-app save or grant an Xbox-console license.

What buying costs today: Xbox examples (2026-11-18)

These are the purchase side of your worksheet, taken from the official US Microsoft Store feed behind our Xbox deals page. We don't quote a subscription price. Enter your own verified one next to these.

Best forGameSale priceRegularOffSale ends
Deepest discountThe Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim Special Edition$7.99$39.99−80%2026-11-20
CheapestDungeon Bricker$2.39$2.99−20%2026-11-21
Most dollars offNBA 2K27 Deluxe Edition$45.00$99.99−55%2026-11-19

Sale prices and end dates change daily. A Microsoft Store purchase is a different license from a PC Steam or catalog copy, so check the platform on the store page.

Use costs you would actually incur

For your chosen planning window, write incremental subscription spend = additional billing you would actually pay + required extras. Then compare purchase spend = the verified game offer + required extras. Use the same tax treatment and content requirements on both sides. Do not charge the subscription route for a paid period you would keep regardless, but do not call future renewals free either.

Leave a line blank if the price, required DLC, or future catalog availability is unknown. A blank is an unanswered question, not zero. This is a reader-filled comparison, not a forecast of your completion time or an assurance that a game will stay available until your preferred finish date.

Two decisions that can legitimately differ

You already have paid access and only want to try the currently included base game. Confirm it is included on PC in your plan and region, and that your PC meets its requirements. Starting there may involve no additional subscription purchase right now. That does not establish that paying for another billing period later will be worthwhile, or that expansions are included.

You want a particular expansion and expect to revisit the game after canceling. Price the compatible base-game license and required content as a separate basket. Paying for DLC does not, by itself, establish continuing access to a subscription base game. Verify current Xbox and game-specific terms before treating an add-on purchase as a substitute for the base-game license. A sale may fit this plan better, but only your actual basket establishes the cost difference.

Buying is a platform license, not a service guarantee

A purchased PC license and temporary catalog access are different arrangements. Neither a purchase nor a subscription guarantees that a required multiplayer service will remain available forever. Check online dependencies separately; see server checks before buying. Also distinguish Xbox-console, Xbox-app PC, and Steam versions: do not assume cross-buy, crossplay, or save transfer without game-specific official confirmation.

A final yes / wait check

Compare actual PC store offers on best deals and the individual game’s deal page; check editions and DLC compatibility before totaling extras. This page has no subscription-purchase call to action.

FAQ

Does buying DLC guarantee continued access to a catalog base game?

Do not assume it does. Verify the base-game license and current platform terms separately from the add-on.

Does this guide quote a monthly Game Pass price?

No. Enter Xbox’s current verified price and your own renewal terms into the worksheet. We do not use a placeholder or hard-coded rate.

Prices and store policies change. This guide reflects what we could verify on 2026-11-08; if you spot something out of date, email hello@crithitdeals.com.

All buying guides · Compare today’s PC deals